Why police shot autistic man’s carer

John Rivera, the President of the Dade County Police Benevolent Association, tried to offer an explanation for why therapist Charles Kinsey was shot three times in the leg while he attempted to coax his 27-year-old autistic client back to a nearby facility in North Miami, Florida.

Rivera said the police officer opened fire because he thought the white individual, whom they later learned is a man with autism, was going to harm Kinsey.

He said the officer was trying to shoot the patient in an attempt to save Kinsey’s life.

“This wasn’t a mistake in the sense that the officer shot the wrong guy or he thought that Kinsey was the bad guy,” he said in a press conference.

“The movement of the white individual made it look like he was going to discharge a fire arm into Mr Kinsey and the officer discharged trying to strike and stop the white man and unfortunately, he missed the white male and shot Mr Kinsey by accident.”

Rivera said that the video footage of the incident was “being portrayed poorly.”

His comments come after eyewitness Thomas Matthews said he tried to tell an officer who had stayed behind for crowd control that the autistic man was only holding a toy truck, not a gun. But she told him to back up.

The officers, he said, grabbed rifles from the patrol cars’ trunks and crept toward the men.

Soon, three shots rang out and Kinsey was wounded.

The shooting drew national attention because much of what happened before the shooting was captured on video.
“If she would have told the other officers, maybe they wouldn’t have shot,” said Matthews, a 73-year-old African-American.

He ran a North Miami flower shop before retiring and has lived in the area for years. He said he has never had a problem with North Miami police.

“But I guess with all the shootings that are going on, they are nervous and shook up,” Matthews said.
 

Monday’s shooting comes amid weeks of violence involving police. Five officers were killed in Dallas two weeks ago and three law enforcement officers were gunned down Sunday in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. Before those shootings, a black man, Alton Sterling, 37, was fatally shot during a scuffle with two white officers at a convenience store. In Minnesota, 32-year-old Philando Castile, who was also black, was shot to death during a traffic stop. Cellphone videos captured Sterling’s killing and the aftermath of Castile’s shooting, prompting nationwide protests over the treatment of blacks by police.

North Miami Police Chief Gary Eugene said the investigation has been turned over to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement and the state attorney’s office.

He called it a “very sensitive matter” and promised a transparent investigation, but refused to identify the officer or answer reporters’ questions.

Eugene, a Haitian-American with 30 years of South Florida police experience, just became chief last week. “I realise there are many questions about what happened on Monday night. You have questions, the community has questions, we as a city, we as a member of this police department and I also have questions,” he said.

“I assure you we will get all the answers.”

Nancy Abudu, the American Civil Liberties Union’s legal director in Florida, said her group hasn’t received any brutality complaints about the North Miami police or about any questionable shootings before this week’s.

Kinsey’s lawyer, Hilton Napoleon II, said he is already talking to North Miami city officials about a monetary settlement for his client, who is married with five children. City officials did not return a phone call seeking confirmation.

Lawyer General Loretta Lynch told reporters the Justice Department is aware of the shooting and working with local law enforcement to gather all of the facts and to decide how to proceed.

U.S. Rep. Frederica Wilson, who represents the area, said she was in shock.

“From what I saw, he was lying on the ground with his hands up. Freezing. But he was still shot,” said Wilson, a Democrat.

“This is not typical of North Miami,” she said. “We’re not accustomed to this tension. ... This cannot happen again.” The chief said officers responded after getting a 911 call about a man with a gun threatening to kill himself, and the officers arrived “with that threat in mind” — but no gun was recovered. Cellphone video shows Kinsey lying on the ground with his arms raised, talking to his patient and police throughout the standoff with officers, who appeared to have them surrounded.

“As long as I’ve got my hands up, they’re not going to shoot me. This is what I’m thinking. They’re not going to shoot me,” he told WSVN-TV (http://bit.ly/2ac7zm1) from his hospital bed, where he was recovering from a gunshot wound to his leg. “Wow, was I wrong.” The video does not show the moment of the shooting. Napoleon said there was about a two-minute gap in which the person who shot the video had switched off, thinking nothing more noteworthy would happen. It then briefly shows the aftermath of the shooting. He would not say who gave him the video.

“Lay down on your stomach,” Kinsey says to his patient in the video, which was shot from about 30 feet away and provided to the Miami Herald (http://hrld.us/2ahReMa). “Shut up!” responds the patient, who is sitting cross-legged in the road.

Kinsey said he was more worried about his patient than himself. “I’m telling them again, ‘Sir, there is no need for firearms. I’m unarmed, he’s an autistic guy. He got a toy truck in his hand,” Kinsey said.

An officer later fired three times, striking Kinsey in the leg, assistant police chief Neal Cuevas told the newspaper.

Napoleon said officers handcuffed Kinsey and left him lying in the street on his stomach for 20 minutes without rendering first aid.

After the shooting, Kinsey said he asked an officer why he was shot and the officer said “I don’t know.”