The Software Patch That Shook the World
![EMIL LENDOF/WSJ, ISTOCK](/uploads/news/2024_07/1721481503.jpg)
A CrowdStrike security update rendered computers unusable, and underscored the fragility of modern global technology.
Hemant Rathod, an Indian executive, was sipping tea in a conference room Friday morning in Delhi, about to send a long email to his team, when his computer went haywire.
The HP laptop suddenly said it needed to restart. Then the screen turned blue. He tried in vain to reboot. Within 10 minutes, the screens of three other colleagues in the room turned blue too.
“I had taken so much time to draft that email,” Rathod, a senior vice president at Pidilite Industries 500331 -1.92%decrease; red down pointing triangle, a construction-materials company, said by phone half a day later, still carrying his dead laptop with him. “I really hope it’s still there so I don’t have to write it again.”
The outage, one of the most momentous in recent memory, crippled computers worldwideand drove home the brittleness of the interlaced global software systems that we rely on.
Triggered by an errant software update from the cybersecurity company CrowdStrikeCRWD -11.10%decrease; red down pointing triangle, the disruption spread as most people on the U.S. East Coast were asleep and those in Asia were starting their days.
“In my 30-year technical career, this is by far the biggest impact I’ve ever seen,” said B.J. Moore, chief information officer for the Renton, Wash.-based healthcare system Providence, whose hospitals struggled to access patient records, perform surgeries and conduct CT scans.
Fixing the problem involved technical steps that confounded many users who aren’t tech-savvy. Some corporate IT departments were still working to unfreeze computer systems late on Friday. CrowdStrike said the outage isn’t a cyberattack.
Adding to the chaos—and further underlining the vulnerability of the global IT system—a separate problem hit Microsoft’s Azure cloud computing system on Thursday shortly before the CrowdStrike glitch, causing an outage for customers including some U.S. airlines and users of Xbox and Microsoft 365.
The CrowdStrike problem laid bare the risks of a world in which IT systems are increasingly intertwined and dependent on myriad software companies—many not household names. That can cause huge problems when their technology malfunctions or is compromised. The software operates on our laptops and within corporate IT setups, where, unknown to most users, they are automatically updated for enhancements or new security protections.
In a 2020 hack, Russian perpetrators inserted malicious code into updates of SolarWindssoftware in a way that compromised a swath of the U.S. government and scores of private companies.
The rising frequency and impact of cyberattacks, including ones that insert damaging ransomware and spyware, have helped fuel the growth of CrowdStrike and such competitors as Palo Alto Networks and SentinelOne in recent years. CrowdStrike’s annual revenue has grown 12-fold over the past five years to over $3 billion.
But cybersecurity software such as CrowdStrike’s can be especially disruptive when things go wrong because it must have deep access into computer systems to rebuff malicious attacks.
Not all updates happen automatically, and computer attacks often occur because people or businesses are slow to adopt patches sent by software companies to fix vulnerabilities—in essence, failing to take the medicine the doctors prescribe. In this case, the medicine itself hurt the patients.
The global outage began with an update of a so-called “channel file,” a file containing data that helps CrowdStrike’s software neutralize cyber threats, CrowdStrike said. The update was timestamped 4:09 a.m. UTC—just after midnight in New York and around 9:30 a.m. in India.
That update caused CrowdStrike’s software to crash the brains of the Windows operating system, known as the kernel. Restarting the computer simply caused it to crash again, meaning that many users had to surgically remove the offending file from each affected computer.
The nature of the patch meant that the impact was uneven, with people in the same office even experiencing the outage very differently. Apple Macs, which don’t use the affected Windows software, were OK, and servers and PCs that weren’t on and internet-connected didn’t receive the toxic update.
CrowdStrike soon realized something was amiss and the update to the file was rolled back 78 minutes later. That meant it wouldn’t affect computers that were off or in sleep mode during that period. But for many of those that were switched on, the damage was done.
In a blog post, CrowdStrike told those users to boot into the Windows “safe mode,” delete the offending file—called C-00000291*.sys—and reboot.
IT teams often can fix problems on employees’ computers using remote-access software—tools that became especially common during the work-from-home boom of the pandemic. But for laptops and other PCs that approach doesn’t work if the machines can’t restart. For those systems, CrowdStrike’s fix had to be done in person—either by a tech-support person on site, or by a regular employee trying to apply the instructions.
Moore, the Washington state healthcare CIO, was away on vacation and initially wasn’t worried when emails about malfunctioning computer applications started landing in his inbox Thursday night.
But by 11 p.m. Pacific time, he had learned that the outage had engulfed the nonprofit health system’s approximately 50 hospitals and 1,000 clinics across seven states. Hundreds of IT employees began deploying patches, which required manual remediation, he said.
Some of the system’s affected computers and devices were fixed by 6 a.m., and most were humming again by 10 a.m. “It will be the end of the day before we get it all done,” Moore said Friday morning.
The time frame for the recovery could be hours or “a bit longer,” he said. Kurtz said on Xthat the outage isn’t “a security incident or cyberattack.”
Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella took to X to offer his own reassurance that the company was working closely with CrowdStrike to bring systems back online. Tesla CEO Elon Muskresponded, “This gave a seizure to the automotive supply chain,” and later said, “We just deleted CrowdStrike from all our systems.”
For Rathod, the senior vice president at Pidilite, the travails didn’t end with his potentially lost email. After switching to his iPad to keep working, he had to rush to the airport for a flight—only to find long lines and flummoxed security staff checking boarding passes manually. Flight information screens weren’t working, so he had to find airline staff to direct him to the right gate.
“It was a mess at Delhi airport,” Rathod said. “How can we depend so much on one company?”
Tom Dotan and Robert McMillan contributed to this article.
Write to Asa Fitch at asa.fitch@wsj.com, Sam Schechner at Sam.Schechner@wsj.com and Sarah E. Needleman at Sarah.Needleman@wsj.com
Keywords
Newer articles