Investigation | Russia represented a historic and lucrative market for Deutsche Bank, fueled by a clientele of state-owned companies with questionable practices and oligarchs with dubious reputations. Even after beginning to pull back in 2014, the bank continued to work with its 'most sensitive clients.'
By Abdelhak El Idrissi and Jérémie Baruch
Deutsche Bank's handling of the risks and scandals linked to Russia perfectly illustrates a well-known dilemma in the banking sector: How do you reconcile the pursuit of profit with compliance requirements?
An analysis of data from the "Inside Deutsche Bank" investigation shows that the German bank often prioritized business interests, even when dealing with wealthy but controversial Russian oligarchs, state-owned companies and financial institutions. This frequently frustrated the compliance officers responsible for fighting financial crime within the group, as well as the teams charged with protecting the bank's reputation.
So much so that, in May 2019, an executive raised the issue at a risk committee meeting – a body tasked with advising the bank's supervisory board on strategy: "The fundamental question is why DB runs this [Russian] business for such a low profit."
Officially, the bank implemented robust frameworks based on a careful classification of clients: those that could be handled locally by its subsidiary, or those that required "escalation" to the regional level, the headquarters in Germany, or even New York for legal risks in the US. Accepting a new Russian client, for example, might require review by several internal committees and teams (compliance, sanctions and embargoes, anti-financial crime, reputational risk committee).
You have 81.21% of this article left to read. The rest is for subscribers only.