It was a perfect case of life imitating art when, in 2002, Jennifer Lopez began planning the biggest wedding in US history that never was.
With a budget of more than $3 million and dozens of chandeliers flown in from Italy, it was set to be the sort of decadently maximalist affair that would have made Mary, her perfectionist character in The Wedding Planner, beam with pride.
And then came the single wedding detail that broke everything, when Lopez and groom-to-be Ben Affleck realised they could not go through with their September 2003 extravaganza.
Obsessed with entertainment news? Download our new app and never miss a headline
“When we found ourselves seriously contemplating hiring three separate ‘decoy brides’ at three different locations, we realised that something was awry,” the couple said in a statement.
The nuptials they had planned would have done Louis XIV proud. Affleck proposed with a $3.7 million, 6.1 carat pink diamond ring, the rehearsal dinner was to be held at a $43 million Montecito mansion with a dancefloor constructed over the pool, before 400 guests, along with 14 ushers and bridesmaids, would watch them wed at a luxury hotel in Santa Barbara with the bride in a $30,000 bespoke Vera Wang dress.
(The Wedding Planner is available to stream on Tubi)
The wedding even had an ‘ambience designer’ named Edgardo Zamora who later told the New York Times: “She wanted the wedding to be like The Great Gatsby. It was hard to find chandeliers fancy enough for her – ‘More crystal! I want more crystal!’ So I got 25 of them, from Italy. And then she cancels it all!’’
And then in September 2003, four days before it was all meant to start, kaboom! It was over.
It would take Lopez nearly 20 years, until 2022, two husbands, two divorces later, and one failed engagement later, that Lopez started talking about what really happened to Bennifer 1.0.
Some context: for anyone unlucky enough to have not been plugged into the early aughties Us Weekly/TMZ matrix, Bennifer was the first great celebrity couple of the 21st century (and first portmanteau). Since meeting on the set of Gigli, they had become the Burton and Taylor of the flip phone generation and it’s hard to overstate the pop culture, and paparazzi, gravitational pull they exerted.
They tried to take a very meta poke at the situation in her 2002 video for Jenny from the Block, in which Affleck starred as himself, an epically miscalculated move that saw them come in for a drubbing.
It was only in 2024, speaking to Variety, that Lopez opened up about how the video “wound up turning out ugly for us in the media.
“We never thought that people would take offence or be angry at us… We were so naive,” Lopez told Variety in 2004.
Then came another epic turkey. Gigli finally hit theatres in August 2003 and it was uniformly savaged. One critic said, “nothing can quite prepare you for how bad Gigli is”.
For example, in one scene, Lopez’s character suggests that Affleck’s inept gangster perform oral sex on her with the line, “It’s turkey time! Gobble, gobble, gobble.”
“I was eviscerated,” Lopez told Vanity Fair in 2017 of the reaction to Gigli. “I lost my sense of self, questioned if I belonged in this business, thought maybe I did suck at everything.”
Even though the couple were “so in love. It was one of the happiest times of my life,” Lopez told Rolling Stonein 2022, the critical drubbing they were getting “really destroyed our relationship from the inside out.”
And so, four days out from the wedding the whole thing blew up, with Lopez and Affleck announcing the wedding was being postponed, before officially splitting months later.
However, in Lopez’s 2024 documentary, The Greatest Love Story Never Told, she finally admitted that they had actually broken up three days before the wedding, saying “we just crumbled under the pressure.”
She later said the split was “the biggest heartbreak of my life. I honestly felt like I was going to die”.
It would be 19 years before the star-crossed lovers finally made it down the aisle, first in Las Vegas and then in an opulent to-do at his Geroge estate. (This time around, he proposed to her in her favourite spot, a bubble bath.)
Unfortunately, as The Wedding Planner’s lovelorn Massimo tells Lopez’s Mary, “Love can’t always be perfect. Love is just love.”
In 2025, Bennifer divorced.
This week, during a radio interview, Lopez revealed the advice that had helped her in the wake of the end of this marriage.
“I had a therapist who told me — I was like … I’m f**king everything up, you know? … He was like, ‘You’re so young. Just keep going. Keep discovering yourself and learn to love every part of yourself in that way. Even the parts that are the hopeless, romantic, and all of that.’ ”
So, a Jennifer 3.0? You know what they say about third times.
(The Wedding Planner is available to stream on Tubi)